Downtown Historic District The downtown historic district contains a significant collection of commercial buildings, dating from the first half of the 1800s to about 1950, as well as residential, religious, and other building types. The contributing buildings represent a wide range of architectural styles, including Federal, Greek Revival, Italianate, Renaissance Revival, Beaux Arts, Neoclassical and Chicago Commercial. Generally, the oldest buildings are located on Main Street, which is significant for its high concentration of Federal and Greek Revival style buildings. As the city grew and prospered, many Italiante structures were constructed on State, Pearl and Market streets. The district was listed in the National Register of Historic Places in 1999. Information on individual properties from Downtown walking tour brochure and from other research by Floyd County Historian Dave Barksdale, and from National Register of Historic Places nomination, prepared by the Westerly Group. Listings
ONeill-Brown House 210 Bank Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Queen Anne
Year Built: 1903
This property was purchased from the First National Bank in May 1902 by Elizabeth Meyer for $337.50. The rear brick portion of the structure was originally used as the bank cashiers living quarters for the Indiana State Bank.
Commercial building 311 Bank Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1950
house 312 Bank Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: gable-front
Year Built: c.1860
Levi Block 319 Bank Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Neoclassical
Year Built: 1906
Dr. L.D. Levi had this office building constructed in 1906 in the Neoclassical style.
This townhouse, along with 218, 220 & 224 East Main Street, was built for Simeon K. Wolfe, a prominent New Albany lawyer. He used them for investment purposes and rented this property out for at least 25 years.
Insurance agent Thomas Danforth had this Greek Revival townhouse built by January 1854, and entrepreneur John Briggs purchased it about four years later.
commercial building 213 East 4th Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1940
This building was once used as a roller skating rink.
commercial building 215 East 4th Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Constructed in 1879, the Tabernacle Baptist Church had an auditorium that was considered to be the finest in New Albany at the time. The congregation moved to a church at East Ninth and Spring streets in 1920, where it remains today.
industrial building 217 East 5th Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1960
house 221 East 5th Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: shotgun
Year Built: c.1900
Demolished 2014
Bethel A.M.E. Church 315 East 5th Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Greek Revival
Year Built: 1864
This simple, temple-front Greek Revival building was built in 1864 as a German Methodist church. It has been owned by the Bethel A.M.E. Church since the early twentieth century.
house 317 East 5th Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: American Foursquare
Year Built: c.1910
Sapinsky Block 101 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Renaissance Revival
Year Built: 1896
Clothiers Jacob Sapinsky & Son had this ornate Renaissance Revival-style building constructed in 1896, by New Albany contractors S. Day and Sons.
Commercial building 105-107 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1870
This circa 1870 building has held a number of uses through the years, including a cigar and billiards shop, a stationery store, and a barber shop.
Scribner House 106 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Federal
Year Built: 1814
The oldest remaining building in New Albany, the Scribner House was constructed in 1814 by founding father Joel Scribner. The Piankeshaw Chapter of the Daughters of the American Revolution has owned the house and operated it as a museum since 1917.
Commercial building 109-111 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1880
Like its neighbor to the west, this building has housed multiple different commerical uses before becoming part of the Schmitt Furniture complex.
Clapp Block 110 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1868
Built in 1868 in the Italianate style, this business block contained a Masonic hall for the Dudley Temple of Honor on the third floor.
Commercial building 113 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1870
This building was home to the Second National Bank for many years in the late 19th and early 20th century.
This structure was constructed around 1860. The earliest use of the building is unknown, but it was used off and on by various printing businesses from 1868 until 1956.
A flour mill was located in this building as early as 1856, and the building itself may be earlier. It later housed a shirt factory, among many other uses. After an extensive rehabilitation, it was rededicated as New Albany City Hall in September 2021.
commercial building 147 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1870
commercial building 151 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
It appears that Jefferson Conner had this building constructed shortly after he purchased the lot in November 1856 for $2,000. He was partners with Frank Gillett in the dry goods concern of Conner & Gillett.
Indiana State Bank 203 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Greek Revival
Year Built: 1837
Built in 1837 as one of the ten original branches of the Indiana State Bank, this building is generally recognized as one of the state's finest examples of the Greek Revival style.
Jacob Bader Building 209 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1885
Jacob Bader, prominent New Albany businessman, had this three-story brick business house built in 1885.
commercial building 211 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: contemporary
These townhouses - along with one to the east, at 224 East Main, and one to the south, at 43 East Third - were built by attorney Simeon K. Wolfe for investment purposes.
Constructed circa 1850, half of this building was occupied by druggist W. T. Courtney in the 1850s. It has housed a variety of other uses since, and was used as apartments during much of the 20th century.
Trio House 224 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150
Year Built: 1878
This townhouse - along with two to the west, at 218 and 220 East Main, and one to the south, at 43 East Third - were built by attorney Simeon K. Wolfe for investment purposes.
Second Baptist Church 300 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Greek Revival
Year Built: 1849-52
New Albany architect and master builder Isaac P. Smith built this structure between 1849-52, for the congregation of Second Presbyterian Church. It is also commonly known as the 'Town Clock Church,' because the clock can be seen throughout downtown and from the Ohio River.
house 310 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: gable-front
Year Built: c.1870
This structure may have been built as early as 1860, but was either rebuilt or significantly remodeled circa 1880. It was demolished in 2021 for a new mixed-use development on the site.
commercial building 311 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: modern
This building housed tobacco-related uses from its contruction until about World War I. It was demolished in 2021 to make way for a new mixed-use development.
parking lot 325 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150
This parking lot was previously the site of an early service station. Prior to that, several buildings containing both businesses and residences were located here.
Redmen Building 401 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: contemporary
Year Built: 2005
This brick building was constructed in 2005 as the new home of the Redmen Club, after they moved from their long-time location in the Samuel Culbertson mansion at 904 East Main.
commercial building 413 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: contemporary
Year Built: c.1980
A federal-style brick residence once stood on this site.
Biel Cottage 415 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: shotgun
Year Built: c.1887
This unusual brick shotgun house was built sometime after 1886 by the Biel family.
house 417 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Federal
Year Built: c.1850
commercial building 419 East Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1930
commercial building 102 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: c.1880
Built circa 1880, this corner commercial building was once home to the St. Charles Saloon, while the upper floor housed Maennechor Halle.
The Globe Store 109 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1875
This Italianate-style building was constructed for Louis Goodbub in 1875 at a cost of $4500, and later was home to the Globe Department Store for many years.
William Gamble Building 110-112 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: c.1859
This Italianate style building was constructed circa 1859, and initially housed a coffee house and a saloon.
Martin Kiefer Saloon 113 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: gable-front
Year Built: c.1870
This simple, gable-front building was constructed circa 1870. Although the earliest use was as a saloon, the building housed a drugstore from 1929 until the mid-1990s.
This building is believed to be the oldest frame commercial building remaining in New Albany, dating to the 1840s.
Reibel House 115 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Renaissance Revival
Year Built: 1887
As early as 1859, Joseph H. Reibel was running a saloon and boarding house on East Market Street. This building, constructed in 1887, replaced a two-story structure that he had been using for his business and residence since 1865.
Phillip Kent Building 117 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1861
Phillip Kent had this three-story, Italianate structure built in 1861 for use as his bakery.
Ben Briggs Building 119 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1891
This Italianate building, constructed in 1891, replaced a structure that had been built in New Albany's earliest years.
John Briggs Block 123 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1872
John Briggs purchased this lot - which included an older building - for the hefty sum of $9025 in 1871, and this building was completed the next year. From 1931 until 1973, Woolworth's occupied this space, as well as the two buildings to the west.
Wilcox Building 133-135 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1869
Dr. Peleg M. Wilcox had this block of buildings constructed in 1869 in the Italianate style, incorporating a c.1840 building into the new construction at 135.
commercial building 134 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1940
Losson Block 137 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1891
Built in 1891, this building housed the Fair Store, a popular downtown clothing shop, from the 1930s until 1989. A painted "ghost sign" for the business remains visible on the west wall.
Grand Theater 138 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Art Deco
Year Built: 1909 Year Renovated: 1915/1950
Built as a stage and movie theater in 1909, The Grand was remodeled and enlarged in 1913. It was remodeled again in 1950, taking on its current appearance.
Little Chef Diner 147 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Art Moderne
Year Built: 1957
This diner was produced in 1957 by the Valentine Manufacturing Company, of Wichita, Kansas.
Monsch Hotel 148 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1871
John T. Monsch had this "European style" hotel built in 1871, in the Italianate style of architecture. The facility operated as a hotel for more than a century.
Farmers Market 200 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150
Year Built: c.1980
Odd Fellows Building 201 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Renaissance Revival
Year Built: 1874
This building was constructed in 1874 by master builders James and William Banes for the Independent Order of Odd Fellows. The structure is still home to New Albany Lodge #1, the first Odd Fellows Lodge organized in the Hoosier state.
The buildings at 207-209 East Market were built as one residence in 1858, but have also incorporated a commercial use since their earliest days.
commercial building 211 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: contemporary
Year Built: c.1960
vacant lot 215 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150
A Federal-style commercial building once stood on this site, now a vacant lot.
commercial building 222 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: contemporary
Year Built: c.1980
commercial building 302 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: c.1880
commercial building 308 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1920
commercial building 322 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: contemporary
Year Built: c.1960
commercial building 324 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Federal
Year Built: c.1860
commercial building 401-403 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: c.1890
commercial building 402 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: modern
commercial building 407 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1950
house 419 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: American Foursquare
Year Built: c.1910
commercial building 421 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1920
This tiny building, rehabbed in 2018 as an office, began as a gas station.
Dietz-Luette Building 424 East Market Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: c.1895
This turn-of-the-century building has housed a bar and/or restaurant for much of its existence.
bank building 100 East Spring Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: modern
Year Built: 1963
This modern bank building was built around 1963 on the site of the Floyd County Courthouse.
The Elsby Building 117 East Spring Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Neoclassical
Year Built: 1916
Designed by Joseph & Joseph Architects of Louisville, KY, the Elsby Building was constructed in 1916 on the former site of the 1866 Masonic Temple. The Neoclassical-style building cost $100,000 to construct and was advertised as being fire-proof.
The church now known as St. Mark's United Church of Christ has its roots in a 'German Evangelical, Lutheran and Reformed Congregation' established in 1837.
Centenary Methodist Church was established in 1839, and the congregation occupied its original church building until relocating in 2019. This Greek Revival structure has seen numerous changes through the years - and has now been adapted for residential use - but retains much of its historic character.
Built in the days of horse-drawn fire apparatus, this building remained in active service until the mid-1970s, when a new station was constructed at West 10th and Main streets.
Commercial building 406 East Spring Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: contemporary
Year Built: c.1970
Henry L. Graf House 414 East Spring Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Arts and Crafts
Year Built: 1915
This 1 1/2 story brick house, dating to 1915, replaced a frame, Victorian structure that previously stood on the lot.
German Methodist Church 418 East Spring Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Gothic Revival
Year Built: 1890
This Gothic Revival structure was constructed 1889-90 as the second church for German Methodists in New Albany.
This Neoclassical-style building was constructed in 1903 by the noted local contracting firm Stephen Day & Son, and was first occupied by tailor John J. Morgan and his Great One Price Clothing and Department Store.
The Merchants National Bank was founded by New Albany businessmen Jacob Hangary and Robert McCord. This structure was built in 1869 on the former site of an 1830 bank.
Built by the end of the Civil War, this building served the demands of the thriving retail and wholesale districts of downtown New Albany. The earliest tenants of the building are unknown, but by 1882 Josiah Gwin had his publishing company here.
commercial building 209 Pearl Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Neoclassical
Year Built: c.1910
This building was built using similar materials and design to the adjacent Morgan Building at 201 Pearl Street, but probably was constructed slightly later.
commercial building 211 Pearl Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
This Italianate was constructed in 1888 and was originally two storefronts. The ornate facade was encased in a metal slipcover in the mid-20th century, which was removed as part of the building's recent rehabilitation.
commercial building 214-216 Pearl Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
This was the first New Albany location of retail giant F.W. Woolworth Company, beginning in about 1913. About ten years later, the first Woolworth's Cafeteria in the nation opened on the second floor here.
Originally home to a barber shop and a saloon, this Italianate style structure later housed long-time New Albany businesses Cohn Shoes and Ray's Jewelry Store.
This was the home of S.W. Newburger & Company's White House Department Store, a mainstay in downtown New Albany for almost a century.
Lang Block 227 Pearl Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: c.1855
The original owner of this block of buildings was Thomas Conner. When constructed circa 1855, there were four different storefronts, three facing Pearl Street and one facing Market.
Eurton's Cafe was located in this Neoclassical-style building for a number of years after its construction circa 1900.
Herbst Building 312 Pearl Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1868
Merchant tailor M.S. Herbst was the original business in this 1868 structure, and occupied this space for a number of years.
Switow Building 314 Pearl Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Neoclassical
Year Built: 1914
Built in 1914 on the former site of the Crystal Theater, this building was home to long-time New Albany business J.O. Endris Jewelers from 1976 to its closure in 2014.
Frank and Jacob Zinsmeister purchased this lot for $6500 in September 1890, but did not have this building constructed for over a decade. The Neoclassical-style structure was built on the former site of the M.V. Mallory Livery Stable.
Hieb Building 316-318 Pearl Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1870
This Italianate style building was constructed in 1870 for clothier and merchant tailor John Hieb. In addition to its architectural beauty, the building is notable as having had the first American-made, ground and polished plate glass windows, which hung in the storefront.
This building was constructed in 1900 by New Albany contractors S. Day & Sons, to house John Baer's dry goods and department store, established in 1871.
commercial building 322-324 Pearl Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: contemporary
Year Built: 1951
This building stands on the site of the Mutual Trust Bank, and has gone through many transformations through the years.
Kaiser Building 326 Pearl Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1886
Kaiser's Tobacco was founded in 1832 and is New Albany's oldest continuous business. This brick building was constructed in 1886 for Mrs. Josephine Kaiser by master builder John Naifus.
This urban oasis was created from a parking lot, to celebrate the city's 2013 Bicentennial. Prior to the parking lot, the site had been home to the magnificent Post Office and Customs House.
The Opera House was constructed in 1866 at a cost of $100,000, and seated 2500 patrons for its performances. The building was extensively remodeled following a 1939 fire, including the removal of the third floor.
The mural on the side of this building was completed by noted local artist Carrie Johns in 2022, and includes a depiction of the New Albany Opera House.
Built in 1860 for different owners and different businesses, this two structures were combined to house a single business - Brown's Seed Store - by the 1890s.
This Art Moderne building was built in 1937 and is still home to a Firestone service station. It is believed to be the only Firestone station of this style still being used for its original purpose.
This modern bank building was constructed on the site of the Floyd County Jail.
commercial building 207 West 1st Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: vernacular
Year Built: 1922
This building was constructed in 1922 as a delivery entrance for the Rowe-Fawcett Wholesale Grocery Company, which occupied Woodward Hall from 1908 to 1936.
commercial building 108 West Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Federal
Year Built: c.1850
Neafus Saloon 116 West Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: c.1882
Built in 1882 as a saloon and now home to a barbeque restaurant, this building has always housed some type of restaurant, saloon or tavern.
Shrader Stables 118 West Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1875
In 1875, John Shrader, Sr. and son George had this Italianate-style building constructed for their livery business.
Woodward Hall 128 West Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Egyptian Revival
Year Built: 1852
The concave cornice at the roofline and above the storefront show the influence of the Egyptian Revival style. The building was constructed in 1852 for dry goods wholesaler John Woodward, and included the city's first public hall on the third floor.
Israel House Hotel 142 West Main Street New Albany, IN 47150 Category: Italianate
Year Built: 1842
Andrew and Mary Israel purchased this lot in 1842 and built this well-known hotel and boarding house. The Israel House, known as the finest hotel in the city, operated here for more than forty years.