George A. Bicknell, father to Judge George A. Bicknell, Jr., took up residency next to his son in the late 1850s. The property was sold to Dr. Seymour Wilcox in September 1868 for $4200. The west side of the home was used as the Wilcoxs' residence, while the east side was Dr. Wilcox's office. The house remained in the Wilcox family through the early 1950s. The photo below shows the home as it appeared in 1973.