Built in 1882 and first used to house the David B. Neafus Saloon, this building has housed a number of different taverns and other establishments over years, including the Sunny Side Saloon and the Joseph A. Renn Saloon. The photo below shows the building in 1973, when it was home to Shirl-Ray's Bar.

Developer Steve Resch and restauranteur Ryan Rogers undertook a complete rehabilitation of the building in 2012, garnering a 2013 Facelift Award from the New Albany Historic Preservation Commission.